NCAA Tournament on CBS: Announcers

    
March 19th, 2009
3.06
Average: 3.1 (21 votes)
Your rating: None
Hoops on TV

Hoops on TV


When you watch as much of the NCAA Tournament as us die-hards do.. you inevitably form close bonds with the announcers on CBS. Some strong congenial bonds.. others I could do without.  Here is the CBS college basketball roster, including links to profiles on CBS.com, their role during the broadcast, and my rating of their recent work. 

 

For 2009, we have a huge change as Clark Kellogg replaces Billy Packer as lead color-man alongside Jim Nantz. Interesting that CBS replaced Packer, who was easily the network's worst commentator for the past handful of years, with Kellogg.. who I've always felt was the second worst CBS had to offer. Give CBS a nod for consistency. Also new this year, we have Greg Anthony replacing Kellogg in the booth, young Carter Blackburn spelling Dick Enberg, and Craig Bolerjack making his D1 tourney debut.

 

C is considered your run of the mill broadcaster, neither exceptional nor annoying. On the most part, CBS does a good job with their coverage, hence mostly respectable grades (as opposed to a similar report card I could do for ESPN...)

 

A Ian Eagle (Announcer)

A- Bill Raftery (Color)

B+ Jim Nantz (Announcer - FF)

B+ Greg Gumbel (Studio)

B Jay Bilas (Color)

B Kevin Harlan (Announcer)

B Verne Lundquist (Announcer)

B Lesley Visser (Sideline)

B- Greg Anthony (Studio, New 2009)

B- Len Elmore (Color)

C+ Stephen Bardo (Color)

C+ Seth Davis (Studio)

C+ Dick Enberg (Announcer)

C+ Gus Johnson (Announcer)

C+ Jim Spanarkel (Color)

C Carter Blackburn (Announcer, New 2009)

C Craig Bolerjack (Announcer, New 2009)

C Dan Bonner (Sideline)

C Tim Brando (Anouncer)

C Mike Gminski (Color)

C Bob Wenzel (Color)

C Tracy Wolfson (Sideline)

D+ Clark Kellogg (Color - FF)

 

Notes:

Gus Johnson is slowly but surely growing on me. Anthony has made a nice transition into his studio role, and continues to improve. A lot of people dislike Nantz and Gumble, but these guys are professionals who consistently get the job done. Dick Enberg's a legend, but his peak days are in the rear at this point.  Crater Blackburn is a young Syracuse guy who seems to be on the network's fast-track.

 

No Longer Part of CBS Team

B- Sam Ryan (Sideline)

D Billy Packer (Retired)

 

Comments

Philda Wisecarver's picture

CBS Announcers vs Raycom Sports

The announcers are very disppointing. I have been watching and attending SEC basketball games all season, as we usually do. Whether you watch or attend, if you do it faithfully, you get to know the players and coaches, as well as their personal stories.

The Raycom staff knew the players and coaches personally and admired and respected them. It is obvious as they interview them, and listening to them call a game, they pronounce their names correctly and don't repeat stories from the beginning of the season. The CBS announcers tell stories that are no longer relevant about the players and make silly comments about the length of player's hair and shorts.

If you are going to have the tournament games, as I understand you are from now on, please get some younger announcers, preferably some former SEC players who understand the players of today and the fans of today. There are a lot of players who have graduated in the last 15 years with degrees in Sports Information or Broadcasting. Sure they are looking for employment!

Thank you for your time.

Anonymous's picture

NCAA announcers for Gonzaga vs NC

I think announcers could show some class and not call playing abilities "weapons" it shows such uneducated slang. Get a life announcer, show your educated and there's more to life than the street.

Anonymous's picture

Steven Bardo higher rating

Steven Bardo higher rating than Gus Johnson?!? You're crazy

J. Kaminski's picture

announcers

Gus Johnson is my favorite, especially when the game gets exciting. My least favorite is Dan Bonner, who is a master of saying the obvious.

Enjoy the site.

jk

Anonymous's picture

basketball announcers

I do not understand these rankins. Clark Kellogg is ranked last with a D rating. He is my favorite and I am just upset that I was not allowed to help Billy Packer pack with his anti-Al McGuire mentality. Verne Lunquist is a bit of a "used car salesman".

will's picture

gus johnson

Gus Johnson is a true Gem. He is the best announcer in sports right now. C for him C'mon

Anonymous's picture

BOZO Announcer - Mizzou, NOT Missoula

Who is the BOZO announcer who keeps calling 'Mizzou,' Missoula? Doesn't he know the difference between the two? I mean, really, there's a pretty BIG difference.

CBS should be ashamed of hiring someone who doesn't know their schools and the difference. And, why doesn't someone correct him? Are they all BOZOs? At the very least, he owes Mizzou fans a REALLY BIG APOLOGY for such a blunder.

CBS should only hire announcers who know the schools and their nicknames, etc. Get RID of this guy! URGHHHHH

HoopsJunkie's picture

Announcers Ignorance

Okay I've had a belly full. I'm convinced these guys have never read a rule book. There's not such thing as a "loose ball foul" in college basketball; that's an NBA rule. A "flagrant" foul in college basketball results in ejection. These guys just show their ignorance when they use terms like this wrong. Might be fine distinctions, but these guys are paid to get it right. Also, nowhere in the rulebook does it say a player must be "set" to draw a charge. That term is only used with regard to a legal screen. Would someone, anyone, of these guys please read what constitutes legal guarding position and what must be done to commit a player-control foul? And heaven forbid they might have to understand what an airborne shooter is and how that works.

Some of the worst are ex-players and ex-coaches. Just because you've coached or played doesn't mean you know the rules, let alone their finer points and interpretations.

If ignorance is bliss, Ian Eagle is ecstatic.

Anonymous's picture

Gus Johnson is perhaps the

Gus Johnson is perhaps the most exciting and exhilarating commentator known to man. I almost enjoyed his commentating more than the kansas st/xavier game itself, which was a JEM to say the least. Way to go CBS on landing a legit sportscaster who truly loves what he does. Two thumbs up Gus and keep on truckin buddy.

Anonymous's picture

Gus Johnson

I find Gus Johnson to be extremely boring and very annoying. His voice is irritating I turn off the sound and watch the game. He sounds more like a radio announcer. We can see what is going on. Does he realize that? I think a C is a very high grade for him

Anonymous's picture

I enjoy Clark Kellog calling

I enjoy Clark Kellog calling the games. I look forward to his descriptive comments of the action on the court. A D+?....shawn seagull must be wacky.

nrolfes2's picture

Gus Johnson

How does Gus Johnson only have a C+? He is easily the most exciting announcer out of them all, he deserves definitely an A.

d martin's picture

Commentators on tnt

like havin more channels to watch tournament, but the guys who called Ohio St. and Texas -sa were totally pathetic. Those guys would never make it on the radio because they did no play by play just because OSU were ahead by 30 points. At least act like your watching the game morons!

Going to Carolina's picture

Clark Kellogg

Since when do commentators get to have a favorite team when commentating on games? Washington was obviously Clark Kellogg's favorite in Sunday's NCAA mens tournament. How about hiring commentators who can be fair and unbiased. No one really cares what they think!

Anonymous's picture

NCAA MENS BASKETBALL COMMENTATORS

I have always thought college basketball announcers on TV sound like a bunch of used car salesmen from New Jersey. Do the networks think being a former high school basketball coach in NJ is the expert experience needed to cover collge basketball......the worst is Mr Dukie Dickie V....How much does Duke and NC pay this clown to promote their basketball programs every year on TV? This country is brain washed to think the ACC IS the best conference in college basketball. Take away Duke and NC and what is left in the ACC?

Anonymous's picture

Since when did the word

Since when did the word "strenGth" become strenth? Many announcers pronounce it this way and it drives me crazy. Just heard it again on CBS tonight during the Duke/Arizona game. Aargh!

Anonymous's picture

Charles Barkley

I love the addition of Sir Charles and Kenny Smith to the CBS analysis team. Charles is so raw and straight up, does not over analyze the situation, just calls it straight and tells it like it is. Some commentators want to get too deep for my personal tastes, it's only basketball, come on people. I also like Kenny very much, just wish they would have traded in Greg for Ernie Johnson, now that would have been a "dream team".

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options